By Theresa Gibilisco, owner, The Hungry Puppy
We stock two Nutrena scratch blends next to each other, and customers ask about the difference about once a day. The quick version: both are treats, Hi-Pro just packs more into each handful. Here's the side by side.
On the tag
| Nutrena Hi-Pro Scratch Grains | Nutrena Country Feeds Scratch Grains | |
|---|---|---|
| Crude protein (min) | 12% | 7.5% |
| Crude fat (min) | 5% | 2.5% |
| Crude fiber (max) | 8% | 8% |
| What's in it | Grains, black oil sunflower seeds and high protein pellets, with added vitamins and minerals | A blend of whole and cracked grains |
| Probiotics | Yes, four strains on the tag | Not listed |
| Labeled for | Adult poultry 16 weeks and up; a treat after 8 weeks | Adult poultry |
| How much | Less than 10% of the diet | No more than 10% of the diet |
| Bag sizes | 7 lb and 50 lb | 50 lb |
What the extra protein gets you
Scratch's biggest downside is that it's low in protein, and every handful replaces some of the 16% layer feed your hens need. Nutrena Hi-Pro Scratch narrows that gap. At 12% protein, it doesn't water down the diet as much as a 7.5% scratch does. The sunflower seeds and higher fat also make it more energy dense, which is why Nutrena pitches it for peak laying season and cold weather.
What it doesn't do is replace layer feed. At 12%, it's still well below what a laying hen needs, and its calcium is nowhere near layer levels. Nutrena says to pair it with a complete poultry feed and keep oyster shell and grit available free choice.
When regular scratch is all you need
Country Feeds Scratch Grains is the simple, classic choice. If you toss a small handful in the afternoon to get the girls scratching around, and your hens are laying well on their layer feed, regular scratch does that job fine.
When I'd pick Hi-Pro
- You give treats every day and want each handful to count for more.
- It's winter and you like giving the flock something extra on cold days.
- Your hens love sunflower seeds and you're tired of buying them separately.
- You want a smaller 7 lb bag for a small flock.
Either way
- Layer feed stays the main meal, available all day.
- Scratch stays under 10%, roughly what they'll clean up in 10 minutes.
- Grit goes out in its own dish. Whole grains and seeds need grinding.
- Store it dry and sealed. Seeds and grains draw mice.
Looking for a treat that's built around egg quality instead of grain? NatureWise TidBits mix scratch with nutrient bits in Healthy Egg and Immunity Support versions.
On the truck with your feed
Both scratches come to your backyard with your feed on our own trucks, Tuesday through Friday on your town's route day, free with a $20 minimum. See our backyard chicken feed page and farm feed delivery page, or call 732-938-4470. For the full story on treats and the rest of the diet, see what chickens eat.