By Theresa Gibilisco, owner, The Hungry Puppy
Walk down a feed aisle and the protein numbers jump out at you: 16%, 17%, 18%, 20%, even 22%. It's natural to assume higher is better. For laying hens, it isn't that simple, and the most common answer I give is the least exciting one. A good 16% layer feed is what most backyard hens need.
Where 16% comes from
Sixteen percent is the standard protein level for complete layer feeds. Nutrena's own scratch grains guidance says laying hens need at least 16% protein in their diet. Purina's Layena and organic layer feeds are 16%, and so is our everyday Nutrena layer.
Nutrena Country Feeds Layer 16% Crumble is Nutrena's economical complete layer feed. From the tag:
- Crude protein 16% minimum, with lysine 0.7% and methionine 0.3% minimum
- Crude fat 2.5% minimum, crude fiber 8% maximum
- Calcium 3.4% to 3.9%
- Prebiotics and probiotics
Nutrena's directions: feed it as the sole ration starting at 16 weeks of age, don't let the feeder run empty, provide grit as needed, and oyster shell or coarse ground limestone from the onset of lay. The crumble form encourages hens to eat, and it's an easy switch for pullets coming off chick crumbles.
The part nobody puts on the bag: treats lower the number
The protein on the tag is the protein of the feed, not of everything your hens eat. Here's simple math. Nutrena's Country Feeds Scratch Grains are 7.5% protein. If your hens eat 90% layer feed at 16% and 10% scratch, the whole diet works out to a little over 15%. If treats creep up to a quarter of the diet, you're closer to 14%.
Nutrena notes too much scratch can lower egg output and slow molt recovery. That's usually the real reason a flock on a 16% feed seems to be struggling. Before you buy a higher protein feed, cut the treats back to 10% and see what happens.
When a higher number makes sense
- 17%: NatureWise Layer 17% Crumble gives a little more protein, plus Nutrena's herbal blend and more probiotics. A nice step up if your hens get a fair amount of treats or yard time.
- 18%: NatureWise Hearty Hen, soy-free with flaxseed, and NatureWise Harvest Blend, a textured feed with whole grains and seeds you can see.
- 20%: Feather Fixer, for the molt. Purina recommends around 19% protein while hens regrow feathers.
- 22%: Country Feeds Egg Producer, a special order feed made to be mixed with scratch for free-range hens, so the combined diet comes out balanced.
Is more protein ever a problem?
For healthy hens on a complete feed made for layers, the higher protein layers are fine. They're just not necessary for every flock. What does matter is calcium. Whatever protein level you pick, make sure it's a layer feed with layer calcium, or that you have oyster shell out.
My rule of thumb
Start with a good 16% layer and oyster shell on the side. Keep treats to about 10%. Watch your hens: steady laying, good shells, full feathers. If they look great, you're done. If you're seeing thin feathers, heavy treat feeding you can't give up, or a hard molt, step up to 17% or 18%.
Bags that come to you
We stock Country Feeds Layer 16% in crumble and pellet, plus the NatureWise layers, in Farmingdale. Our own trucks deliver Tuesday through Friday on your town's route day, free with a $20 minimum. See our backyard chicken feed page and farm feed delivery page, or call 732-938-4470. Comparing brands too? See Nutrena vs. Purina, tag by tag.